I came across an article earlier this month detailing a study performed by the University of Pittsburgh. It warned that parents should pay close attention if their kids are listening to a lot of music, because teenagers who listen to a uniquely copious amount of music are more likely to have major depression.
This notion had the Parents’ Music Resource Center (PMRC) written all over it. Between high school and college, I completed two research papers focusing on music censorship. A major component of the issue revolved around Tipper Gore and the PMRC in the 1980s. They worked to establish the Parental Advisory stickers we see on albums today. Efforts were also concentrated on explicit artists that were believed to have a major influence on the way listeners acted. Artists like Marilyn Manson have been blamed for teen suicide as a result of extreme lyrics.
I am not here to debate the validity of those cases. Instead, I found myself faced with a serious problem with the recent study. Upon further reading, I realized it was not based on the PMRC rationalization at all. The conclusion was simply that teens diagnosed with depression more often chose to spend their time listening to music over other media, like reading or watching television. They drew the obvious conclusion, that the participants were turning to music to help deal with their feelings.
Music "may provide companionship in a way for people,” said Dr. Primack.“It may be specific songs about loss or difficulty they find solace in or identify with. There's sort of [that] in the purpose of music since it began."
Although the study does not directly link music to the cause of depression, the article suggests that parents be wary of a child who listens to music and shows signs of the disease. It shines a negative light on the study, making it seem more than a simplistic look at what depressed individuals do in their spare time.
To suggest that the correlation between music and feelings of sadness is a bad thing is not only biased, but completely unfounded. Primack stated himself that these individuals can find solace in music.
Sadness isn’t the only emotion connected to music. In each and every emotion we go through in the day, a song can be associated with it. Have you ever been driving in your car and skipped a song on your iPod because it’s not what you feel like hearing at that moment? The notion that a song can change your day, attitude or state of mind is what I love about music. Personally, I have playlists dedicated to exercising, going out and falling asleep. The songs on these lists have been chosen because of how they make me feel and the attitude they induce.
Once you assign a particular track to a feeling, person or situation, it stays that way forever. Under no circumstances will you forget how that song made you feel. There have been many situations in my own life that one song – one great chorus – has helped me get through. If there’s anyone out there that hasn’t found that, I am sorry for you. There is no greater healing than the power of music.
Confessions of a Broken Heart by Lindsay Lohan (although I wish a different artist would've written this song, it is one track that has spoken to me more than any other)